Menu
Search
Filters
Close
Menu

11356 Root Cause Analysis of Cracking in a Stainless Steel Clad Plate in a Gas Scrubber Unit

Picture for 11356 Root Cause Analysis of Cracking in a Stainless Steel Clad Plate in a Gas Scrubber Unit
Available for download
Product Number: 51300-11356-SG
ISBN: 2011 11356 CP
Author: Abdul Razzak Al- Shamari, A. Al- Mithin, Amer Jarragh, Santosh Kumar, S.S Prakash, Moavin Islam
Publication Date: 2011
$0.00
$20.00
$20.00
The stainless steel cladding plate of a Gas Scrubber unit in a gas processing facility (called a Booster Station), belonging to the Kuwait Oil Company developed cracking on the shell after about 10 years in service. The carbon steel base material was unaffected. Since the cracking was somewhat unusual for the type of cladding material under normal operating conditions of a Gas Scrubber, a Root Cause Analysis (RCA) exercise was undertaken to identify the cause of cracking.

The RCA exercise involved an ‘Events and Causes Analysis’ and a concomitant failure investigation which included Positive Metal Identification (PMI) of the alloy material, in-situ microstructural examination of the alloy material, and chemical analysis of the incoming fluids. PMI indicated that a mix up of materials had taken place wherein instead of the specified SS 316L cladding plate, a SS 321 cladding plate had been inadvertently used. The microstructural examination revealed that the cracking was intergranular and was most likely due to sensitization. Fluid analysis results indicated that sudden high spurts in chloride concentration in the incoming process fluid had occurred, particularly during the last two years of operation. The operating conditions of the scrubber unit coupled with the high chloride concentrations were conducive to the development of Intergranular SCC in the 321 grade stainless steel.

Keywords: Root Cause Analysis (RCA), stress corrosion cracking (SCC), 321 stainless steel
The stainless steel cladding plate of a Gas Scrubber unit in a gas processing facility (called a Booster Station), belonging to the Kuwait Oil Company developed cracking on the shell after about 10 years in service. The carbon steel base material was unaffected. Since the cracking was somewhat unusual for the type of cladding material under normal operating conditions of a Gas Scrubber, a Root Cause Analysis (RCA) exercise was undertaken to identify the cause of cracking.

The RCA exercise involved an ‘Events and Causes Analysis’ and a concomitant failure investigation which included Positive Metal Identification (PMI) of the alloy material, in-situ microstructural examination of the alloy material, and chemical analysis of the incoming fluids. PMI indicated that a mix up of materials had taken place wherein instead of the specified SS 316L cladding plate, a SS 321 cladding plate had been inadvertently used. The microstructural examination revealed that the cracking was intergranular and was most likely due to sensitization. Fluid analysis results indicated that sudden high spurts in chloride concentration in the incoming process fluid had occurred, particularly during the last two years of operation. The operating conditions of the scrubber unit coupled with the high chloride concentrations were conducive to the development of Intergranular SCC in the 321 grade stainless steel.

Keywords: Root Cause Analysis (RCA), stress corrosion cracking (SCC), 321 stainless steel
Product tags
Also Purchased
Picture for 11361 Processing and Fabricating Alloy 825 for Optimized Properties and Corrosion Resistance
Available for download

11361 Processing and Fabricating Alloy 825 for Optimized Properties and Corrosion Resistance

Product Number: 51300-11361-SG
ISBN: 2011 11361 CP
Author: Lewis Shoemaker and Jim Crum
Publication Date: 2011
$20.00
Picture for 11358 Refining Industry Experience with HF Unit Flange Face Corrosion and Detection for API RP 751
Available for download

11358 Refining Industry Experience with HF Unit Flange Face Corrosion and Detection for API RP 751

Product Number: 51300-11358-SG
ISBN: 2011 11358 CP
Author: Michael Nugent, Willis Perry, Timothy Reeves and Steve Bacon
Publication Date: 2011
$20.00
Picture for 11351 The Corrosion of Superduplex Stainless Steel in Different Types of Seawater
Available for download

11351 The Corrosion of Superduplex Stainless Steel in Different Types of Seawater

Product Number: 51300-11351-SG
ISBN: 2011 11351 CP
Author: R Francis, G Byrne and G Warburton
Publication Date: 2011
$20.00

Superduplex stainless steels have been used in seawater systems since 1986 as castings and since 1990 as wrought product. The present paper describes some of the service environments commonly in use and the conditions that give rise to specific operating potentials. The limits of use under these conditions are described utilizing both laboratory and service experience.
Categories
Industry
Recently viewed
Popular tags
View all

Association for Materials Protection and Performance

© AMPP All Rights Reserved.
Membership Terms of Content Use
Contact Customer Support